Doing Manager Work Without Manager Pay

In today’s workplace, many employees find themselves taking on additional responsibilities without a corresponding increase in pay. If you’ve been handed manager-level duties without the manager-level salary, you’re not alone.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: you should have an open conversation with your boss about getting properly compensated for the higher-level work you’re doing. However, there are tactful ways to approach this conversation and actions you can take to demonstrate your value.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll cover why this situation happens, how to build a case for a raise or promotion, tips for negotiating pay, what to do if your request is rejected, and when it may be time to find a new job that properly compensates your skills.

Why You’re Doing More Work Without More Pay

Many employees find themselves in a situation where they are taking on additional responsibilities and doing more work without receiving a corresponding increase in pay. This can be frustrating and demotivating, especially when you see others being promoted or receiving higher salaries.

There are several reasons why this may be happening.

Being a top performer

If you consistently excel in your role and go above and beyond what is expected of you, it’s possible that your employer sees you as a valuable asset and relies on you to handle additional tasks. While this may be a compliment to your abilities, it’s important to communicate your expectations for fair compensation with your employer.

Don’t hesitate to discuss your workload and the possibility of a pay raise.

Company growth without promotions

In some cases, a company may experience significant growth and increased workload without the corresponding ability to promote employees or adjust compensation. This can be due to budget constraints or a lack of available positions.

If you find yourself in this situation, it’s important to have an open and honest conversation with your supervisor or HR department about your concerns. They may not be aware of the impact this is having on your job satisfaction.

Lateral move gone awry

Sometimes, employees may volunteer or be asked to take on additional responsibilities as part of a lateral move within the company. While this can be a great opportunity for growth and development, it’s important to ensure that the terms of the move are clearly defined and agreed upon.

If you find yourself doing more work without the promised compensation or recognition, it’s important to address the issue with your manager or HR department.

Budget limitations

One common reason why employees may be doing more work without more pay is budget limitations. Companies may be facing financial constraints that prevent them from offering salary increases or promotions.

While this may be frustrating, it’s important to consider the overall financial health of the company and the potential for future growth. It may be helpful to explore other forms of compensation such as additional vacation days, flexible work hours, or professional development opportunities.

Remember, it’s essential to advocate for yourself and communicate your concerns with your employer. By having open and honest conversations about your workload and compensation, you can work towards a solution that is fair and satisfactory for both parties.

Making a Case for Better Compensation

Are you working tirelessly, taking on managerial responsibilities, but not receiving the compensation you deserve? It’s time to make a case for better pay. Here are some steps you can take to advocate for yourself and ensure you are fairly compensated for the work you do.

Track your responsibilities and accomplishments

Start by keeping a detailed record of your daily tasks, projects, and achievements. Documenting your responsibilities will provide concrete evidence of the value you bring to the organization. When discussing compensation with your employer, you can refer to this list to demonstrate the breadth and depth of your managerial work.

Benchmark your market value

It’s important to understand your market value and how it compares to industry standards. Research salary ranges for similar positions in your industry and location. Websites like and provide valuable information on average salaries for different job titles.

Use this data to support your case for better compensation.

Get feedback from colleagues

Reach out to your colleagues, both within and outside the organization, to gather feedback on your performance as a manager. Positive testimonials and endorsements from your peers can strengthen your case for a pay raise.

Their insights can provide valuable evidence of your effectiveness and the impact you have on the team and organization.

Polish up your resume

Update your resume to reflect your managerial responsibilities and accomplishments. Highlight specific projects you have successfully led, teams you have managed, and any measurable results you have achieved.

A strong resume that showcases your managerial skills and achievements will help support your request for better compensation.

Consider asking for a title change

If you have been performing managerial duties without the corresponding title, it may be worth discussing a title change with your employer. A title that accurately reflects your responsibilities can have a significant impact on your perceived value within the organization and can potentially lead to better compensation.

Remember, advocating for better compensation is about demonstrating your value and the impact you have on the organization. By tracking your responsibilities, benchmarking your market value, gathering feedback, updating your resume, and considering a title change, you can make a compelling case for the pay you deserve.

Tips for Negotiating Pay

Schedule a meeting focused just on this topic

When it comes to negotiating your pay, it’s important to give this topic the attention it deserves. To ensure that your request is taken seriously, schedule a meeting with your supervisor specifically to discuss your compensation.

This shows that you are serious about your worth and that you value your contributions to the company.

Frame it as a discussion, not a demand

Approach the conversation with your supervisor as a discussion rather than a demand. Use phrases such as “I would like to discuss my compensation” or “I would like to explore the possibility of a salary adjustment.”

By framing it as a conversation, you create a more collaborative atmosphere and increase the chances of a positive outcome.

Be prepared with evidence

Before entering the negotiation, gather evidence to support your request for a pay increase. This can include data on industry standards for your job role, examples of your exceptional performance, and any additional responsibilities or tasks you have taken on.

By presenting concrete evidence, you demonstrate your value to the company and strengthen your case for a higher salary.

Suggest a trial period

If your supervisor is hesitant to immediately grant your pay increase, consider suggesting a trial period. This allows you to prove your worth and showcase the value you bring to the organization. Propose a specific timeframe, such as three months, during which you can demonstrate your capabilities and reassess your compensation at the end of the trial period.

Ask what you can do to get to the next level

Inquire about what you can do to advance to the next level in terms of both responsibility and compensation. This shows your commitment to growth and development within the company. By asking for feedback and guidance, you demonstrate that you are willing to put in the effort to improve and deserve a higher salary.

What to Do If Request for Raise is Rejected

Getting a rejected request for a raise can be disappointing and frustrating. However, there are several steps you can take to navigate this situation and still make progress in your career. Here are some things you can do:

Get clarity on reasoning

When your request for a raise is rejected, it’s important to understand the reasoning behind the decision. Schedule a meeting with your supervisor or HR representative to discuss their rationale. This will help you gain clarity on any performance issues or company constraints that may have influenced the decision.

By understanding their perspective, you can better address any concerns and work towards a future raise.

Ask for Performance Goals

One way to demonstrate your commitment to growth and advancement is by setting performance goals. Request a meeting with your supervisor to discuss specific objectives you can work towards. By having clear goals, you can show your dedication to improving your skills and performance, which may increase your chances of a raise in the future.

Request a timeline for review

If your request for a raise has been rejected, it’s important to have a timeline for when you can revisit the topic. Ask your supervisor or HR representative for a specific date or timeframe when they would be open to reviewing your salary again.

This will give you a sense of when to follow up and provides an opportunity to demonstrate your growth and achievements within that time period.

Negotiate non-monetary perks

While a raise may not be possible at the moment, you can still negotiate for non-monetary perks that can improve your overall job satisfaction. Consider requesting additional vacation days, flexible work hours, or the opportunity to work on more challenging projects.

These perks can enhance your work-life balance and professional development, making your current situation more appealing.

Update resume and LinkedIn profile

Even if your request for a raise is rejected, it’s important to continue investing in your career. Update your resume and LinkedIn profile with any new skills, projects, or achievements you have gained since your last performance review.

This will help you stay prepared for potential job opportunities that may arise in the future.

Remember, a rejected request for a raise does not mean the end of your career growth. By taking proactive steps and maintaining a positive attitude, you can still make progress and position yourself for future success.

When It’s Time to Move On

Working hard and taking on additional responsibilities is commendable, but there may come a time when you realize that you’re doing manager-level work without receiving manager-level pay. This can be frustrating and demoralizing, but it’s important to recognize when it’s time to move on and seek better opportunities.

Here are a few signs that indicate it may be time for a change:

If repeated requests are denied

If you’ve been consistently performing at a higher level and have repeatedly requested a promotion or a salary increase, but your requests have been consistently denied, it may be a clear indication that your current organization does not value your contributions.

In such situations, it may be time to start exploring other opportunities where your efforts are recognized and rewarded.

If you’ve significantly outgrown your role

It’s not uncommon for individuals to outgrow their current roles as they gain more experience and develop new skills. If you find yourself constantly seeking new challenges and feeling unfulfilled in your current position, it may be a sign that you’ve outgrown your role.

Moving on to a new job that aligns with your current skillset and offers room for growth can be a great way to continue advancing in your career.

If there’s no career path for advancement

One of the key indicators that it may be time to move on is the absence of a clear career path within your current organization. If there’s no opportunity for growth or advancement, it can be difficult to stay motivated and engaged in your work.

Exploring new options where there is a clear path for progression can reignite your passion and help you achieve your professional goals.

If there’s a toxic culture around compensation

A toxic culture around compensation can be highly detrimental to your overall job satisfaction. If you find that your organization consistently undervalues its employees and fails to provide fair compensation for the work being done, it may be time to consider other opportunities.

Remember, you deserve to be fairly compensated for your efforts and skills.

Remember, recognizing the signs that it’s time to move on does not mean you are giving up or failing. It simply means that you are taking charge of your own career and seeking better opportunities for personal and professional growth.

Trust your instincts, be proactive, and don’t settle for less than you deserve.


Taking on higher-level responsibilities without fair pay is unfortunately common. However, you have more power than you think when it comes to getting properly compensated, whether that’s at your current company or at a new organization that recognizes your value.

With the right framing, evidence to demonstrate your contributions, and understanding of what motivates your boss and company, you can negotiate your way to manager pay – even without the manager title. However, be prepared to walk away if your requests continually go unheard.

Your skills and time are precious, so advocate for your worth or find it elsewhere.

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts