How Much Does Buffalo Exchange Pay For Clothes? The Complete Breakdown

Looking to make some extra cash by selling your used clothes? If so, you may be wondering how much Buffalo Exchange pays for clothes. As one of the most popular resale and vintage clothing stores around, Buffalo Exchange can be a great place to get cash for your old threads.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: Buffalo Exchange pays anywhere from 20-30% of what they expect to sell the items for. The exact amount depends on the brand, condition, and current demand for the type of clothing.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll break down Buffalo Exchange’s buying process, how they determine payout amounts, what brands they look for, what condition clothes need to be in, and tips to get the most money for your items.

How the Buffalo Exchange Buying Process Works

When it comes to selling your clothes at Buffalo Exchange, the process is simple and straightforward. Here is a breakdown of how the buying process works:

You Bring in Your Items

The first step in the Buffalo Exchange buying process is to bring in your gently used clothing items to one of their store locations. Whether you have a few pieces or a whole bag full, their friendly staff will be there to assist you.

It’s always a good idea to call ahead and check if the store is currently accepting items, as some locations may have specific buying hours or restrictions.

Employees Sort Through and Evaluate

Once you bring in your items, Buffalo Exchange employees will sort through and evaluate each piece. They have a keen eye for fashion and are knowledgeable about current trends and brands. They will carefully inspect the condition of each item, looking for any signs of wear or damage.

They will also consider the overall style, quality, and desirability of the items.

Offers are Made Based on Resale Value

After the thorough evaluation, Buffalo Exchange will make offers based on the resale value of your items. The offers are typically calculated by considering factors such as brand, condition, style, and current market demand.

Buffalo Exchange aims to offer fair prices to sellers while also ensuring they can resell the items at a reasonable profit.

You Accept or Decline the Offer

Once the offers are made, it’s up to you to accept or decline them. If you accept the offer, you will receive cash or store credit on the spot. If you decline the offer, you can take back your items without any obligation.

It’s important to note that the offers made by Buffalo Exchange are non-negotiable, as they have their own pricing guidelines based on their market research and experience.

What Factors Determine How Much You Get Paid

When selling your clothes at Buffalo Exchange, several factors come into play that determine how much you will be paid. These factors range from the brand and condition of your items to current trends and demand, as well as seasonality.


The brand of your clothing plays a significant role in determining its resale value at Buffalo Exchange. Popular and high-end brands tend to fetch higher prices compared to lesser-known or generic brands.

Brands like Nike, Levi’s, and Free People are generally in high demand and can command a higher price.


The condition of your clothing is another crucial factor that affects how much you will be paid. Items that are in excellent condition, with no signs of wear or damage, will generally receive a higher payout.

It’s important to make sure your clothes are clean, free from stains, and have all their buttons and zippers intact to maximize their resale value.

Current Trends and Demand

The current trends and demand for specific styles or items also influence how much Buffalo Exchange is willing to pay. If a particular fashion trend is in high demand and customers are actively seeking it, you may receive a higher payout for those items.

Keeping an eye on the latest fashion trends can help you identify which pieces in your wardrobe might fetch a higher price.


The seasonality factor also affects the amount you can expect to receive for your clothes. Buffalo Exchange operates on a buy-sell-trade model, which means they consider the current season when determining the resale value of your items.

Clothing items in high demand for the upcoming season will receive a higher payout, while items that are out of season may receive a lower offer.

It’s important to keep in mind that these factors can vary based on location and market demand. Therefore, it’s always a good idea to check with your local Buffalo Exchange store or visit their official website to get the most accurate information regarding their current buying guidelines and pricing policies.

The Brands Buffalo Exchange Looks For

When it comes to selling clothes at Buffalo Exchange, they have a specific list of brands they look for. Here is a breakdown of the types of brands they are interested in:

High-End Designer Brands

Buffalo Exchange is known for its curated selection of high-end designer brands. They are always on the lookout for luxury labels like Gucci, Chanel, Prada, and Louis Vuitton. If you have any gently used pieces from these top-tier designers, you might be in for a nice payout!

Mall Brands

Don’t worry if you don’t have any high-end designer items to sell. Buffalo Exchange is also interested in mall brands that are popular among shoppers. Brands like Zara, H&M, Forever 21, and Urban Outfitters are all on their radar.

So, if you have trendy clothes from these stores, you can still make some cash.

Vintage and Specialty Brands

Buffalo Exchange has a soft spot for vintage clothing and specialty brands. If you have unique vintage pieces or items from independent designers, you might have a chance to sell them at Buffalo Exchange.

This is a great opportunity to showcase your individual style and make some money at the same time.

Niche and Indie Labels

Buffalo Exchange also values niche and indie labels. They appreciate the creativity and uniqueness that these brands bring to the fashion industry. So, if you have clothes from emerging designers or lesser-known labels, Buffalo Exchange might be interested in adding them to their inventory.

Keep in mind that Buffalo Exchange’s brand preferences may vary slightly depending on the location and current trends. It’s always a good idea to check with your local store to see if they have any specific requests or guidelines for the brands they are currently looking for.

For more information on the brands Buffalo Exchange looks for, you can visit their official website at

What Condition Do Clothes Need to Be In?

When selling clothes to Buffalo Exchange, it is important to understand the condition they need to be in. The store has specific requirements to ensure they can resell the items and provide customers with high-quality clothing options.

No Stains, Holes, Pilling, or Fading

Clothes that are stained, have holes, excessive pilling, or fading are generally not accepted by Buffalo Exchange. The store aims to offer clothing in good condition to their customers, so it is essential that the items you bring in meet these criteria.

This means checking for any visible stains, tears, or signs of wear and tear before you consider selling them.

No Broken Zippers or Missing Buttons

Buffalo Exchange looks for clothes with intact zippers and all buttons present. If a zipper is broken or buttons are missing, it can affect the overall functionality and appearance of the garment. To maximize your chances of selling your clothes, it is essential to inspect and repair any broken zippers or replace missing buttons.

Clean with No Odors

Another requirement is that the clothes you bring in should be clean and free from any odors. This includes both visible dirt and any unpleasant smells. Washing or dry cleaning your clothes before selling them will increase the likelihood of Buffalo Exchange accepting them.

Gently Used and Still Stylish

While Buffalo Exchange does accept used clothing, they prefer items that are still in style and in good condition. It’s important to remember that the store aims to provide trendy and fashionable options to their customers. So, if your clothes are outdated or heavily worn, they may not be accepted.

It is always a good idea to review Buffalo Exchange’s guidelines on their website to ensure you meet all the requirements before bringing in your clothes. This will save you time and increase your chances of selling your items successfully.

Tips to Get the Most Money for Your Clothes

When selling your clothes at Buffalo Exchange, there are several tips you can follow to maximize the amount of money you receive. By taking a few extra steps, you can ensure that your items are highly desirable and fetch a higher price.

Clean and Press Items

First impressions matter, even when it comes to selling clothes. Make sure your items are clean, fresh-smelling, and free of any stains or damage. Take the time to properly wash or dry clean your clothes, and consider ironing or steaming them to remove any wrinkles.

By presenting your items in the best possible condition, you increase their appeal and the likelihood of receiving a higher payout from Buffalo Exchange.

Bring in Coveted Brands

Buffalo Exchange has a strong demand for certain brands and labels. If you have clothes from well-known designers or popular brands, you have a better chance of receiving a higher payout. Check Buffalo Exchange’s website or visit their store to see which brands they are currently seeking.

By bringing in coveted brands, you increase the likelihood of your items being selected for resale and receiving a higher payout.

Sell in Season Styles

Buffalo Exchange pays attention to the current trends and seasons. Selling clothes that are in style and appropriate for the current season increases the chances of getting a higher payout. For example, if it’s winter, focus on selling coats, sweaters, and boots.

By aligning your items with what customers are currently looking for, you increase their desirability and the likelihood of receiving a higher payout.

Bundle Similar Items

Another tip to maximize your earnings at Buffalo Exchange is to bundle similar items together. For example, if you have multiple t-shirts or accessories that go well together, present them as a set. This allows you to showcase multiple items at once and potentially negotiate a higher price for the bundle.

By packaging similar items, you add value and increase the chances of receiving a higher payout.

Check Buffalo Exchange Website First

Prior to bringing your clothes to Buffalo Exchange, it’s a good idea to check their website for any specific guidelines or requirements. They may have certain items they are currently not accepting or have specific guidelines on how to present your items.

By being aware of these details, you can save time and ensure that your clothes meet the store’s criteria, increasing the likelihood of a successful sale and a higher payout.


Selling your gently used clothing to Buffalo Exchange can be a great way to clean out your closet and get paid at the same time. While you won’t receive full retail value, you can typically get 20-30% of the expected resale price in cash or store credit on the spot.

To maximize your payout, be selective about which items you bring in by sticking to current, on-trend pieces from designer brands that are in excellent condition. With the right items and some preparation, you may be surprised at how much extra money you can earn!

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts