Is South Park: The Fractured But Whole Worth It? Analyzing This Controversial Sequel

South Park: The Fractured But Whole is the 2017 sequel to the popular South Park: The Stick of Truth RPG. This time around, the vulgar humor and parody are turned up to 11. But is the actual gameplay worth it?

We’ll analyze the pros, cons, and controversy to determine if Fractured But Whole is worth your time and money.

If you’re short on time – Fractured But Whole is an entertaining RPG for South Park fans, but has repetitive combat and a high controversy level. It’s worth playing for the story at a discount price.

Fractured But Whole’s Gameplay and Mechanics

When it comes to gameplay and mechanics, South Park: The Fractured But Whole offers a unique and engaging experience that sets it apart from its predecessor. The game introduces several new features and improvements that enhance the overall gameplay and make it a worthwhile sequel.

Turn-Based Combat System

One of the standout aspects of Fractured But Whole is its turn-based combat system. Taking inspiration from classic role-playing games, the combat in this game is strategic and requires careful planning.

Players must strategically position their characters and choose the right abilities to defeat enemies. This system adds depth to the gameplay and keeps players engaged throughout their journey.

Expanded Character Customization

Another notable improvement in Fractured But Whole is the expanded character customization options. Players have a wide range of choices when it comes to creating their own unique character. From choosing their superhero class to selecting their appearance and abilities, the game offers an impressive level of customization.

This allows players to truly immerse themselves in the South Park universe and tailor their character to their liking.

Co-Op Multiplayer Integration

Fractured But Whole also introduces co-op multiplayer integration, allowing players to team up with friends and tackle challenges together. This cooperative gameplay adds a new dynamic to the game, as players can strategize and coordinate their actions to overcome obstacles.

Whether it’s fighting enemies or solving puzzles, the co-op mode provides an enjoyable and social experience for players.

The South Park Story and Humor

When it comes to the South Park franchise, one thing is clear – it is not afraid to push boundaries and challenge societal norms. The creators of the show, Trey Parker and Matt Stone, have crafted a unique world filled with absurdity, satire, and biting social commentary.

This distinct style of storytelling is also evident in the video game adaptation, South Park: The Fractured But Whole.

Absurd Story and Settings

South Park: The Fractured But Whole takes players on a wild adventure through the fictional town of South Park. The game’s story revolves around the kids of the town, who have formed superhero personas and are engaged in an epic battle against each other.

The absurdity of the storylines and settings is a trademark of the South Park franchise, and it is no different in this game.

The game takes players on a journey that includes everything from battling supervillains to exploring sewers and even traveling back in time. These outlandish scenarios contribute to the game’s charm and provide players with a unique gameplay experience that is unlike anything else on the market.

References to the Show and Culture

One of the highlights of South Park: The Fractured But Whole is the game’s numerous references to the show itself and popular culture. Fans of the show will delight in spotting familiar characters, locations, and even catchphrases as they progress through the game.

The game also takes aim at current events and social issues, using its trademark brand of humor to provide commentary on topics such as politics, religion, and celebrity culture. This blend of pop culture references and social satire adds depth and relevance to the game, making it more than just a simple spin-off of the TV show.

Vulgar, Irreverent Humor Style

It is important to note that South Park: The Fractured But Whole is not for the faint of heart. The game embraces a vulgar and irreverent humor style that is characteristic of the South Park franchise. Profanity, sexual innuendos, and crude humor are all present throughout the game.

While this humor may not be everyone’s cup of tea, it is an integral part of what makes South Park: The Fractured But Whole unique. It serves as a reflection of the show’s irreverent nature and allows players to fully immerse themselves in the world of South Park.

The Controversy Around the Game

Accusations of Racism and Sexism

South Park: The Fractured But Whole, like its predecessor, has faced accusations of racism and sexism. Critics argue that the game uses offensive stereotypes and derogatory language, particularly towards certain racial and ethnic groups.

However, supporters of the game argue that South Park has always used satire and parody to address sensitive topics, and that the game’s creators are intentionally pushing boundaries to provoke discussion and challenge societal norms.

It is important to note that South Park: The Fractured But Whole is rated M for Mature, indicating that it is intended for players who are 17 years or older. The game’s content is clearly labeled and players are warned of its potentially offensive and controversial nature.

While some may argue that the game goes too far, others appreciate its boldness and willingness to tackle taboo subjects.

For those who are concerned about the potential impact of the game’s content, it is always recommended to research and read reviews before purchasing. Additionally, engaging in open and respectful dialogue about the game’s themes and intentions can help foster a better understanding of its controversial aspects.

Mature Content Warnings

South Park: The Fractured But Whole contains mature content, including explicit language, sexual references, and violence. The game does not shy away from controversial topics and uses its trademark humor to address sensitive issues.

It is important for players to be aware of this before diving into the game.

Parents should exercise caution and consider the age appropriateness of the game for their children. The game’s rating, content warnings, and parental controls can help guide these decisions. Open communication between parents and children about the game’s content can also ensure that everyone is on the same page.

Bans and Sales Restrictions

Due to its controversial nature, South Park: The Fractured But Whole has faced bans and sales restrictions in some countries and retail outlets. Certain governments and organizations have deemed the game’s content inappropriate and have taken measures to limit its availability.

It is essential to respect the laws and regulations of each country and the policies of individual retailers. While some may argue that these bans infringe upon freedom of speech, others believe that they are necessary to protect certain cultural sensitivities and values.

For those interested in purchasing the game, it is advisable to check the availability and any associated restrictions in your region. Online platforms and digital marketplaces often provide clearer access to the game, but it is always essential to understand and comply with local regulations.

Is It Worth Paying Full Price?

One of the main concerns for gamers when deciding whether to purchase a new game is whether or not it is worth paying full price. In the case of South Park: The Fractured But Whole, there are several factors to consider.

Length of the Game

One aspect that gamers often look at when determining the value of a game is the length of gameplay it offers. South Park: The Fractured But Whole provides players with a substantial amount of content.

With an average playtime of around 20-30 hours, players can expect to spend a significant amount of time immersed in the game’s hilarious and satirical world.


Another important factor to consider is the replayability of the game. South Park: The Fractured But Whole offers a high level of replayability, with multiple character classes to choose from and different story paths to explore.

This means that even after completing the main story, players can still enjoy the game by trying out different playstyles and making different choices.

Waiting for a Sale

While some gamers may prefer to wait for a sale before purchasing a new game, in the case of South Park: The Fractured But Whole, it may be worth considering paying full price. The game received positive reviews from both critics and players, praising its humor, gameplay mechanics, and faithful representation of the South Park universe.

By waiting for a sale, players may miss out on the opportunity to experience the game at its full potential.


South Park: The Fractured But Whole delivers an outrageous RPG adventure that only Stone and Parker could create. However, repetitive combat and offensive humor make the full $60 price tag hard to justify.

Ultimately, this sequel is best enjoyed by loyal fans of the South Park franchise who don’t mind excessive controversy. Wait for a sale to get the most value out of this fractured but fun game.

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts