Is Teach For America Worth It? A Detailed Look At The Pros And Cons

Teach for America (TFA) has become an increasingly popular way for college graduates and young professionals to gain experience and give back through teaching in underserved communities. But is participating in TFA really worth it?

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll examine the pros and cons of Teach for America to help you decide if it’s right for you.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: Teach for America can be a rewarding experience for the right person, but requires a significant commitment. The pros are gaining teaching experience, making an impact in high-need communities, and joining a network of TFA alumni.

Cons are the demanding workload, short two-year commitment, and limited teacher training. Do your research to see if TFA aligns with your skills, interests, and career goals.

The Pros of Teach for America

Gain Valuable Teaching Experience

One of the major advantages of joining Teach for America is the opportunity to gain valuable teaching experience. As a Teach for America corps member, individuals are placed in classrooms across the country, where they can develop their teaching skills and make a difference in the lives of their students.

The organization provides extensive training and support to ensure that corps members are well-prepared for the challenges they may face in the classroom. This hands-on experience can be incredibly beneficial for those who are considering a career in education.

Make an Impact in High-Need Communities

Teach for America focuses on placing corps members in high-need communities, where they can have a significant impact on the lives of students who may otherwise have limited access to quality education.

By working in these communities, corps members have the opportunity to address educational inequities and help close the achievement gap. This sense of purpose and the ability to make a positive difference in the lives of students can be incredibly rewarding for those who are passionate about social justice and educational equity.

Join the TFA Alumni Network

Another benefit of joining Teach for America is the opportunity to become part of the TFA alumni network. This network consists of thousands of individuals who have completed the program and gone on to pursue careers in various fields, including education, policy, law, and business.

Being part of this network can provide valuable connections, mentorship opportunities, and resources for career development. The TFA alumni network is known for its strong sense of community and support, allowing former corps members to continue their impact long after their time in the classroom.

The Cons of Teach for America

Heavy Workload and Demanding Commitment

One of the major drawbacks of Teach for America is the heavy workload and demanding commitment that comes with the program. As a Teach for America corps member, you will be expected to teach in underserved schools and work long hours to make a meaningful impact on your students’ lives.

The workload can be overwhelming, with lesson planning, grading, and extracurricular activities taking up a significant amount of your time. The demanding commitment can also take a toll on your personal life, as you may have limited time for social activities or personal pursuits.

Minimal Formal Teacher Training

Another drawback of Teach for America is the minimal formal teacher training provided to corps members. While the program offers an intensive summer training institute, which covers the basics of classroom management and instructional strategies, it may not fully prepare you for the challenges of being an effective educator.

Some critics argue that the lack of extensive training can lead to a steep learning curve for corps members, particularly those without prior teaching experience. It is important to note that Teach for America does provide ongoing support and professional development opportunities throughout the two-year commitment, but the initial training may not be sufficient for some individuals.

Only a Two-Year Commitment

Teach for America requires a two-year commitment from its corps members, which can be seen as a drawback for those who are looking for a long-term career in education. While the program aims to address the immediate need for teachers in underserved communities, some argue that a two-year commitment may not be enough to make a lasting impact on students and the community.

Additionally, transitioning out of Teach for America after the two-year commitment can be challenging, as it may require finding a new job or pursuing further education.

It is important to consider these cons of Teach for America before making a decision to join the program. However, it is also important to note that Teach for America has its merits and can provide a valuable experience for individuals passionate about educational equity and making a difference in the lives of underserved students.

What to Consider Before Applying to TFA

Your Skills, Interests and Career Goals

Before applying to Teach for America (TFA), it is important to consider your own skills, interests, and career goals. TFA is a highly competitive program that seeks driven individuals who are passionate about education and making a difference in students’ lives.

If you have a strong desire to teach and are committed to making a positive impact, TFA can be a great opportunity for personal and professional growth.

If you have a background in education or related fields, such as psychology or social work, TFA can provide you with the necessary training and support to become an effective teacher. However, it is important to note that TFA is not the only path to a successful career in education.

There are other alternative teaching programs and traditional teacher education programs that may better align with your specific skills and interests.

The TFA Time Commitment

One of the key factors to consider before applying to TFA is the time commitment required for the program. TFA is a two-year commitment, during which you will be placed in a low-income community and teach full-time.

The program is known for its rigorous training and demanding workload, so it is important to be prepared for the challenges that come with it.

If you have other commitments, such as family or personal obligations, it is important to carefully consider whether you will be able to dedicate the necessary time and energy to TFA. It is also important to note that TFA alumni often report feeling a sense of fulfillment and personal growth from their experience, but it can be demanding and require a significant amount of dedication and perseverance.

Placement Region and Subject Preference

When applying to TFA, you will have the opportunity to indicate your preferred placement region and subject preference. It is important to carefully consider these preferences and do your research on the regions and subjects you are interested in.

TFA operates in various regions across the United States, each with its own unique challenges and opportunities. Researching the specific needs and demographics of different regions can help you make an informed decision about where you would like to be placed.

Additionally, TFA offers placements in various subject areas, such as math, science, English, and special education. It is important to consider your own strengths and interests when selecting a subject preference.

Keep in mind that TFA may not be able to accommodate all preferences, so it is important to be flexible and open to different placement options.

Alternatives Like City Year and Americorps

Before committing to TFA, it is worth exploring alternative programs such as City Year and AmeriCorps. These programs also offer opportunities to make a difference in underserved communities and gain valuable experience in education.

City Year is a program that focuses on addressing the dropout crisis in high-need schools. Participants serve as mentors, tutors, and role models for students, working alongside teachers and school staff to provide additional support and resources.

AmeriCorps offers a wide range of service opportunities, including education-focused programs. Participants in AmeriCorps can work in schools, community centers, or non-profit organizations, gaining hands-on experience in education while making a positive impact in their communities.

Exploring these alternative programs can help you make a more informed decision about which path aligns best with your skills, interests, and career goals.


Teach for America can be a meaningful way to gain teaching experience, give back, and jumpstart a career in education or social justice. But it requires passion and commitment. Take time to reflect on your skills, interests and career aspirations to determine if TFA is the right fit for you.

Speak with alumni to gain insight into the day-to-day experience. With an informed decision, TFA can be a life-changing opportunity with impact that goes far beyond two years.

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts