Shipt Vs Instacart: Which Pays Better For Shopping And Delivering Groceries?

Grocery delivery services like Shipt and Instacart have exploded in popularity over the past few years. With the tap of an app, you can get everything from produce to pantry staples delivered straight to your doorstep.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: Instacart generally pays more per order than Shipt, but Shipt offers more flexibility in when you work. Shipt shoppers also report higher tips from customers.

In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Shipt vs Instacart pay, fees, flexibility, tips, and more. We’ll help you decide which service could be more lucrative for you as a delivery driver.

How Shipt Works and Pays Shoppers

Shipt is a popular on-demand grocery delivery service that connects customers with personal shoppers. The platform allows customers to conveniently order groceries from their favorite local stores and have them delivered right to their doorstep.

Shipt offers a flexible opportunity for individuals to earn money by becoming shoppers.

Overview of the Shipt platform

Shipt operates through a mobile app, which shoppers can use to browse and accept available orders. Once a shopper accepts an order, they visit the specified store, carefully select and bag the items, and then deliver them to the customer’s address.

Shipt provides shoppers with detailed instructions and guidance to ensure a smooth shopping and delivery process.

Shipt pay structure and earnings

Shipt shoppers are compensated based on the number of orders they complete. They receive a base pay for each order, which can vary depending on factors such as the size of the order and the distance traveled.

In addition to the base pay, shoppers have the potential to earn tips from customers, which can significantly increase their overall earnings.

The exact amount a Shipt shopper can earn varies depending on several factors, such as the number of orders they complete, the time they dedicate to shopping, and the tips they receive. According to Shipt, shoppers can earn an average of $22 per hour.

However, it’s important to note that individual earnings may vary.

Tips from customers

Customers have the option to tip their Shipt shoppers for providing excellent service. Tipping is a way for customers to show appreciation for the shopper’s efforts in ensuring that their groceries are carefully selected and delivered on time.

Tips can range from a few dollars to more substantial amounts, depending on the customer’s satisfaction and generosity.

Shoppers can greatly benefit from providing exceptional service, as it often leads to higher tips and positive feedback, which can increase their chances of receiving more orders in the future. Building a good reputation as a reliable and efficient shopper can result in a steady stream of income.

It’s important for shoppers to remember that their earnings are not solely dependent on the base pay. Going the extra mile to provide exceptional service and ensuring the customer’s satisfaction can significantly impact their overall earnings.

How Instacart Works and Pays Shoppers

Instacart is a popular online grocery delivery service that allows customers to order groceries from their favorite local stores and have them delivered right to their doorstep. The platform connects customers with personal shoppers who pick and pack the items from the store and then deliver them to the customers’ homes.

This convenient service has gained popularity in recent years, especially with the rise of online shopping.

Overview of the Instacart platform

Instacart offers a user-friendly platform where customers can easily browse through a wide range of products, compare prices, and place their orders. Once an order is received, Instacart assigns a personal shopper who is responsible for fulfilling the order.

The shoppers receive the order details, including the specific items and quantities required, as well as any special instructions from the customer. They then head to the designated store to pick up the items.

During the shopping process, the shoppers communicate with the customers to discuss any substitutions or changes that may need to be made if an item is out of stock. This ensures that the customers receive the best possible shopping experience and that their preferences are taken into account.

Instacart pay structure and earnings

Instacart shoppers are paid based on a combination of factors, including the number of items in the order, the distance traveled to deliver the groceries, and the time spent shopping and delivering. Shoppers also have the opportunity to earn additional income through tips from customers.

The pay structure for Instacart shoppers can vary depending on the location and demand for the service. However, on average, shoppers can expect to earn between $15 to $20 per hour, including tips. It is important to note that these earnings can fluctuate based on factors such as the time of day, day of the week, and the shopper’s efficiency.

Tips from customers

Customers have the option to add a tip for their shopper when placing their order. These tips can greatly impact the earnings of Instacart shoppers and are greatly appreciated. Many customers recognize the hard work and dedication of their shoppers and show their appreciation by leaving generous tips.

Instacart encourages customers to consider leaving a tip based on the level of service received. It is important to remember that shoppers rely on these tips as a significant part of their income. By providing a tip, customers not only support their shopper but also help to ensure the continued availability of this convenient grocery delivery service.

For more information about how Instacart works and their pay structure, you can visit their official website here.

Shipt vs Instacart: Key Differences

Order minimums

When it comes to order minimums, Shipt and Instacart have different policies. Shipt requires a minimum order of $35, while Instacart has a lower minimum of $10. This means that if you prefer to shop for smaller orders, Instacart may be the better option for you.

Delivery windows

Both Shipt and Instacart offer convenient delivery windows, allowing customers to choose a time that works best for them. However, the availability of delivery windows may vary depending on your location.

It’s always a good idea to check the available delivery slots in your area before making a decision.

Booking orders in advance

If you like to plan ahead, you’ll be pleased to know that both Shipt and Instacart allow you to book orders in advance. This feature can be particularly useful if you have a busy schedule and want to ensure that your groceries are delivered at a specific time.

Just make sure to check the availability of advance booking in your area.

Flexibility to choose orders

When it comes to flexibility, Shipt and Instacart offer different options. Shipt shoppers have the ability to choose the orders they want to fulfill, allowing them to prioritize based on factors such as distance, time, and compensation.

On the other hand, Instacart assigns orders to shoppers based on their proximity to the store. This means that if you prefer more control over the orders you accept, Shipt might be the better choice for you.

Earnings potential

One of the key factors to consider when choosing between Shipt and Instacart is the earnings potential. While both platforms offer competitive compensation, it’s important to note that actual earnings can vary based on factors such as location, order volume, and tips.

It’s a good idea to research the average earnings in your area and consider factors such as peak hours and customer demand to maximize your earnings potential.

Other Factors to Consider

When deciding between Shipt and Instacart, it’s important to consider other factors beyond just the pay. Here are some additional aspects to keep in mind:

Costs for shoppers

Both Shipt and Instacart have different fee structures for shoppers. Shipt charges a monthly membership fee, while Instacart offers a pay-as-you-go model. It’s important to calculate these costs and consider how they may impact your overall earnings.

Additionally, take into account any additional expenses such as gas and wear and tear on your vehicle.

Ratings and metrics

Both platforms have rating systems in place to evaluate shoppers’ performance. These ratings can affect your ability to receive orders and impact your overall earnings. It’s important to understand the criteria for ratings and strive to maintain a high rating to maximize your earning potential.

Additionally, consider the metrics each platform uses to evaluate shoppers, such as on-time delivery rate and customer satisfaction.

Application and onboarding process

The application and onboarding process for Shipt and Instacart may differ. Research and compare the requirements and steps involved in becoming a shopper for each platform. Consider factors such as background checks, training, and the time it takes to start earning money.

Additionally, read reviews or reach out to current shoppers to get a better understanding of their experiences with the application and onboarding process.

Support for shoppers

Consider the level of support each platform provides to shoppers. This includes customer service, troubleshooting assistance, and access to resources or training materials. Having reliable support can make a significant difference in your overall experience as a shopper and can help you navigate any challenges that may arise.

By taking into account these additional factors, you can make a more informed decision when choosing between Shipt and Instacart. Remember to weigh the pros and cons of each platform based on your personal preferences and needs as a shopper.


When weighing Shipt vs Instacart, there are a few key differences to consider in how the platforms work and how much they pay.

Ultimately, Instacart offers greater earning potential per order, while Shipt provides more flexibility in when you shop. Checking for active demand in your area can help determine which option is a better fit.

By understanding the pay structure, costs, and shopper experience on each platform, you can decide whether Shipt or Instacart is better suited for your grocery delivery needs.

Sharing is caring!

Similar Posts